Site Meter Hunting Sense » Blog Archive » An Anti-Hunting Argument

An Anti-Hunting Argument

by Cliff

Friday, while skimming through stations on the car radio, my wife happened to come across a radio talk-show where they were discussing Alberta’s Provincial Hunting Day. Even though the kids were less than thrilled by the prospect of having to listen to it, my wife left it there so we could listen. I have to say I’m more than a little glad that she did, but I believe she is planning on making a post that may explain why. What I want to discuss is something the anti-hunter they spoke with said.

It is widely agreed that hunting is one of the best management tools wildlife departments have at their disposal. Except to anti-hunters, who will find any reason, no matter how skewered, to debunk the fact. And that is exactly what the anti-hunter on the radio talk-show did, so I wasn’t disappointed. What surprised me though is the way she presented her argument against it.

Her stance is that nature has an established set of checks and balances that will take care of wildlife populations without the intervention of hunters. I don’t agree with her on that point, but I am amazed that she thinks that those checks and balances still actually work with the impact the human race has had on them. Things like the sprawl of our species, the impact we have had on our environment, and the general interference we have had on the entire cycle of nature.

Another issue to take into account is that we, the human race, before we reached our current level of development, played a part in that natural cycle of checks and balances she spoke of. Predation, by us, was a natural part of that cycle until we began moving away from the heritage and necessary activity of hunting.

How can Mother Nature take into account those things? She can’t, plain and simple. That is the reason we see the effects of starvation, overpopulation, in-breeding, and numerous other issues. And since we are to blame for the problems of the wildlife, we need to at least right some of those wrongs. Granted, hunting may seem cruel and barbaric to some, but it has always been a factor. And now it is even more important than ever because of the issues I stated above that we are to blame for.

I don’t know what others actually believe, think, or view this, but I would bet dollar to dollar that many of you feel the same way. I’d like to hear your thoughts.

[tags]hunting, hunting sense, Alberta, Provincial Hunting Day, wildlife management, anti-hunting[tags]


5 Responses to “An Anti-Hunting Argument”

  1. Othmar Vohringer Says:

    Good post Cliff. I am looking forward to the one your wife is going to post on the subject. Maybe you don’t know but almost every Canadian province has a Provincial Hunting Day in the calendar. Ours (BC) is at the same day like Alberta. The provincial hunting day is a newer invention and is catching on fast. Alberta and British Columbia started with that and now more provinces pull along too. In addition, after BC’s new hunter recruitment proposal is made into a law more provinces consider similar pro hunting regulations too. In addition in Ottawa the government works on a bill that will declare hunting as a Canadian heritage.

    With all these happening in favor of hunting I really get for the first time the impression that the antis are on the loosing end and will have a lot of steam taken out of their hypocritical agenda.

    -Othmar Vohringer-

  2. Jon Says:

    Cliff, the antis will never quit and they’ll always be around! As hunters, we all need to stand up to them and I know we are on the correct side of this issue!

  3. Hunting Sense » Blog Archive » Crossing the Line - From the Wife Says:

    [...] had mentioned a little while back that while on a road trip, we were listening to a radio show about hunting, and that I’d be making a post about it at some [...]

  4. Hunting Sense » Blog Archive » Hunting, Ecology, and Ecotourism Says:

    [...] tools utilized when working with specific areas, like food, habitat, and population numbers. And hunting is one of the best, and usually one of the primary, tools used in controlling population, which, in turn, has a direct relationship with all the other [...]

  5. Bill Anderson Says:

    Right on. I think the anti-hunter should be anti-urban sprawl instead. That has actual negative impact. Thanks for posting.

Leave a Reply


About Hunting Sense

Hunting Sense: Where It’s Always Open Season. Can’t get out to hunt? Read about it! Keep up-to-date with what’s going on in the hunting world, learn new tips and tricks from experienced and novice hunters alike, or join in and give us your thoughts on anything hunting related. If you’re out of your tree [stand], HuntingSense.com is the place to be!

Hunting Sense Author(s)
    » Cliff

Sports & Outdoors Channel Posts

Hot Off The Press

  • Day One Highlights from Media Days
    The RazorVision team provides quotes and notes from the first four teams appearing at the Southeastern Conference Football Media Days. Click on the video link for your free view of RazorV [...]
  • Booking Through Thursday - First Lines
    Hello everyone and happy Thursday. Welcome again to yet another slightly late Booking Through Thursday. I reckon I should just start calling it “Booking Through Thursday Afternoon” or “Booking [...]
  • The Mind of the Matter (Part Two)
    Yesterday I confessed to the fact that I don’t trust myself to have chocolate in the house with me when I’m alone during the day. After having a talk with my husband, I began to realize just how [...]
  • News of the Who
    John and his sister Carole in SoCal for a book signing. The fabulous TVShowsOnDVD.com is reporting that the US series one Torchwood Blue-ray DVD set release has been pushed back to 11 November. [...]
  • Housewives (and Husbands...) In the Headlines
    [caption id="attachment_567" align="alignleft" width="125" caption="Doug Savant and wife Laura Leighton"][/caption]Good morning, guys! It seems like the Desperate Housewives people are all over the [...]
  • Underwhleming Talent Example
    I present exhibit A. Having a mage myself but rarely, if ever, speccing fire (I prefer arcane, if you can believe that), I hadn't given much thought to the new fire talents other than "I guess [...]
  • If everybody was like me, the world would be perfect!
    Bet that title grabbed your eye! But isn't that the way we all feel? If our families would just listen to us, do what we say/recommend/order, then life would be so much easier! At work, [...]
  • Looking for an Eco-Alternative for Fertilizer?
    Turn your own yard leaves in the fall into fertilizer in the summer. Get started these season with these tips. 1. Gather the fallen leaves from your own yard or contact your municipality to [...]
  • Brown bag lecture, "A Summer Story at the Gardens...
    "A Summer Story at the Gardens,"Free for members, price of admission for general public 294-2710 [...]
  • Coco Sumner does her dad proud
    Performing before a large crowd at a charity benefit, Coco Sumner, only 17 years old, is sure making her daddy proud. This young chick's dad only happens to be none other than the legendary Sting, [...]