Site Meter Hunting Sense » Blog Archive » Humans are predators, Not just hunters

Humans are predators, Not just hunters

by Cliff

predators.jpg

In the animal world, its eaten or be eaten, the hunters are doing what mother nature would be doing if we hadn’t removed all the natural predators. Now, it is up to us to do the job.

I ran across the above quote while reading a response to an opinion piece on hunting in a newspaper. As you can tell, it is in support of hunting, not against. And it is a sound argument, even one that I have found myself using from time to time. But after reading it, it got me to thinking.

There are a few things about this argument, as stated here, that are a bit off, and seem to be quite often. First, all the natural predators haven’t been removed. What is more accurate is that we have reduced the number of natural predators to the point that they are no longer effective in naturally controlling the population.

The second is that, as is often the case, it fails to recognize the fact that humans are predators. Our eyes are set in the front of our heads, and our ears are on the side, like is the case with any animal classified as a predator. We were built to hunt, so it isn’t up to us to do the job that other predators are no longer able to, but to be the predators we are and begin actively playing the role nature intended us to play.

It may not be a role that people like to recognize that we have, because for some it may mean having to accept that we are not above nature and that we are no more than animals ourselves, no matter how high the degree of reasoning we have. What that reasoning does do is give us the ability to kill smartly, taking into account all the varying factors needed to maintain a sustainable resource of wildlife.

Of course, this doesn’t change the fact that I believe this is a good and fairly accurate argument. It’s just that I started thinking and thought I would share my thoughts. I guess you could call it a semi-rant, and I rant quite a bit.

, , , , , , ,


2 Responses to “Humans are predators, Not just hunters”

  1. Matt Says:

    Good post. Keep up the good work!

  2. Michael Says:

    Even if we could see the restoration of non-human predators to our public lands and achieve a balance that eliminates hunting… should we?

    I say no, partly because I agree– we are predators and I think there is something restoring about reminding yourself that you are part of nature and trying to act like it, and that denying us this outlet and communion is a mistake.

    And partly because I take the view that game animals are a public resource and we have it in our right to manage them, hunt them, and … well… eat them.

    It is difficult to extract humans from nature and remove our influences, short of returning to stone age hunter gatherer lifestyles seeing as how we’ve been domesticating and managing plants and animals for ~10k years.

    Michael

Leave a Reply


About Hunting Sense

Hunting Sense: Where It’s Always Open Season. Can’t get out to hunt? Read about it! Keep up-to-date with what’s going on in the hunting world, learn new tips and tricks from experienced and novice hunters alike, or join in and give us your thoughts on anything hunting related. If you’re out of your tree [stand], HuntingSense.com is the place to be!

Hunting Sense Author(s)
    » Cliff

Sports & Outdoors Channel Posts

Hot Off The Press

  • The View Schedule May 19-23
    Here is The View schedule for May 19-23. I wonder what the "special announcement" is that they are going to make on Monday? MONDAY, MAY 19 – A “Day of Hot Topics”; the co-hosts interview [...]
  • Green your Own Lawn Naturally, Here's How:
    1. Pick the right kind of grass for your own area: Having grass that's adapted to your own climate area will be a natural grass and end up being less work for you or your lawn maintenance person in [...]
  • David Boreanaz bloopers
    In honor of David's birthday, I thought I'd share a blooper reel that as Boreanaz fans you should enjoy. Sure, it's bloopers of Angel, but hey, Boreanaz is Boreanaz. And besides, it's hilarious! I [...]
  • Matt Hardy Gossip, Media w/ Maria, DVD and Jeff
    Matt Hardy has posted an update on his Myspace. Here are a few excerpts: Touching base with my peeps.. Hi guys and gals, I hope everyone is absolutely fantastic! My life has been uber-insane [...]
  • Bonnets for Breastfeeding
    Since I am still new to breastfeeding, sometimes I find it a little difficult. Especially when I am out in public. Where do I breastfeed that is safe, and private? How do I nurse without my [...]
  • The Real World Lives On
    The Real World will be back for its 21 season. The 7 new roommates will live in a house in Brooklyn. MTV recently changed the format of the Real World from a half hour show to an hour-long show, but [...]
  • ASU fuses sustainability with art
    The topic of sustainability usually involves preserving the Earth and its resources through technology and science. ASU’s Institute for Humanities Research, in the College of Liberal Arts and [...]
  • Who sets the example for your children?
    This is probably going to be a pretty random blog today... kind of my rant against the world. Hang in there with me! Non-believers, and those who would love to portray Christians in a negative [...]
  • Last day, to drop a Session I course wit...
    To drop a Session I course without the drop appearing on the permanent record or counting toward the limit of dropped courses. [...]
  • Mel and Robyn Reach Out To Britney Spears
    Britney Spears,26, is vacationing with actor, Mel Gibson, 52, in Costa Rica. If they seem like an odd couple that's because they are! But these two definitely aren't dating. Mel Gibson is [...]